Dr. James Hollis: When the Psyche Withdraws Consent

When he was 35, Dr. James Hollis fell into a dark, crippling depression—the kind which makes it difficult to even get out of bed in the morning. 

This made no sense to him because he’d just achieved his life goals of creating a family, earning a PhD, and becoming a Professor. 

Not knowing where else to turn, he entered into psychotherapy for the first time.

Gradually, it became clear he’d been chasing goals his culture deemed important, rather than paying attention to what he was calling him from the inside. 

He was so impacted by the therapy that he relocated his family to Switzerland to retrain as a Jungian Analyst at the C. G. Jung Institute in Zurich. 

Although the road ahead was now less certain—and by no means easy (he cleaned homes and toilets to support the transition)—his energy returned in abundance and the depression lifted.

Since, he has gone on to impact countless lives all over the world, through his books, speaking, interviews, and therapeutic work. 

(If you’re unfamiliar, a good starting point is: A Life of Meaning or his interview on TWU’s podcast.) 


A similar thing happened when he was an undergraduate.

Back then, his goal was to make it as a professional footballer.

So all of his energy went towards training for this—while barely scraping by with his studies. 

But Hollis soon found that life had other plans.

Following an injury to his foot, his doctor informed him he’d have to quit football, and that he’d be lucky if he was walking by age forty.

After the initial shock passed, Hollis began to take an interest in his studies for the first time. 

Gradually, the energy he previously invested in football, was redirected towards his intellectual development. 

Ultimately, this personal crisis helped to shape the brilliant mind he maintains to this day at 86.

Had Hollis been spared this injury or his later depression, it’s hard to see how he would have impacted so many lives through his work as a Jungian Analyst, writer, and communicator—and our collective psyche would be a lot more impoverished as a result. 


Hollis’ story reflects an archetypal pattern in human life:

When we’re on path and focusing on the right things, energy flows to us in abundance. 

Conversely, when we’re out of alignment, the psyche withdraws its consent. 

Now, even small tasks require a great struggle. 

Speculating here…  

But this makes me think that each of us has a role to play in something bigger than ourselves.

Almost like we’re one cell in an earthly “body” containing 8 billion+ members. 

And that the creative intelligence of nature (or capital S Self) almost “knows” where the best places to invest our energy are at particular times in life, according to the needs of the whole. 

When our energy is being wasted in the wrong directions—which won’t benefit the collective—nature “lets us know” by withdrawing psychic energy from the previous course of action.

Or sometimes even creating circumstances that make the old path no longer possible —whether it be through injury, depression, mid life crisis, etc.

(See Dr. Lisa Miller’s “red door” exercise here.)

What about you?

When you reflect on your own life, have there been times when you’ve felt off track from your true north? 

And when that’s the case, what tends to happen — both in your inner and outer experience? 

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Picture of Niall McKeever

Niall McKeever

Writer and Founder of The Weekend University. Passionate about making great ideas more accessible.

Read more about me »

7 Insights Newsletter

Once-per-month, I share 7 of the most valuable insights I’ve discovered from books, podcasts, & documentaries in the previous 30 days — handpicked to help you live a more creative, intentional, and meaningful life. Join 51,000+ curious readers and subscribe today.

(I hate spam. You’ll only receive one email every month, and you can unsubscribe at any time.)

2 questions & 2 quotes every 2 weeks to help you find clarity. Add the Question & Quote Newsletter to Your Inbox. 

Before you go...

Interested in reading more books? If so, check out this free guide which shows you 3 simple techniques to 3x your reading speed.