
When I discovered the philosophy of Alan Watts in my early 20s, I was hooked.
Here was a worldview I could resonate with.
One that gave answers to the big questions, and one that restored mystery and wonder to our increasingly disenchanted world.
Naturally enough, I assumed someone who possessed such wisdom had it all worked out.
Which is why I was a little disturbed to later discover that Watts struggled with alcoholism and reportedly had a messy and complicated family life (3 marriages, multiple affairs, and children who described him as a “not really available” father).
This gave me a lot of cognitive dissonance at the time.
How could someone with such brilliant ideas also be the cause of suffering in his own life and in the lives of those closest to him?
It just didn’t add up.
So I’ve since wondered whether we should evaluate a philosophy not by how it makes us feel, or how sophisticated it is, but by the quality of life, relationships, and behaviour of its principal creators.
Now, I’m aware that nobody’s perfect, and we all struggle to live up to our ideals.
But this does raise an important question for the age of the influencer we now find ourselves in.
Think of Osho…
Despite being an advocate for spiritual liberation, he created a cult—now infamous for wiretapping and bioterrorism, while personally accumulating a vast collection of Rolls-Royces.
Heidegger was a card-carrying Nazi.
Jean-Paul Sartre and Simone de Beauvoir were accused of sexual exploitation by former students.
More and more, I’m starting to look at ideas and philosophies almost like “seeds” that we plant in our mind.
And the quality of life, relationships, and actions they produce as their fruits.
In the same way that a disturbed seed planted in polluted soil is unlikely to produce healthy fruit…
What if a philosophy that emerges from an unhealthy (and ethically questionable) way of life is also unlikely to lead to flourishing in those who adopt it?
I suppose the underlying question I’m wrestling with here is…
Can we still benefit from a persons philosophy and ideas—even if that person lives in a way that we wouldn’t want to ourselves?
What are your thoughts?
If you have two mins spare, leave a comment here and let me know.